End Of The Road
Staff Dismissals
Diane is an incredible HR Partner for businesses not ready for in-house. She’s calm, knowledgeable, and always had our back when it came to people matters — big or small. She made tricky situations feel manageable and gave us clear, no-nonsense advice we could trust. If you're looking for a friendly, professional, and genuinely great person to work with, I can't recommend Diane highly enough.Ruth,
Emma at HR Dept was the perfect support for a tricky matter involving a staff disciplinary meeting. So reassuring. We would have no hesitation in recommending Emma and HR Dept to other businesses navigating the minefield of employment law. Thank you!David,
We used the HR Dept to manage a project that involved a significant number of redundancies within a complex context. They were superb- providing us with clear, professional advice at all times and supporting us as a management team as well. In their interactions with employees they were empathetic and effective. Our main contacts were Fintan O'Toole and Ali Day- they were both excellent.Jane,
Professional and responsive, HR Dept have provided us with excellent HR advice and guidance.Townsend House Medical Centre,
Most employers don’t wake up wanting to dismiss someone.
You get here because something isn’t working: performance that won’t shift, conduct you can’t ignore, trust that’s broken down, or a situation that’s becoming disruptive for the wider team.
The problem is that dismissals are one of those HR moments where the stakes spike. One rushed step, one unclear letter, one meeting handled badly, and you’ve created a dispute you didn’t need.
The HR Dept supports employers with staff dismissals and termination of employment decisions, making sure your approach is structured, defensible, and handled professionally.
We can help you with:
- Choosing the right route (conduct, capability/performance, redundancy, SOSR)
- Running a clear dismissal procedure (without dragging it out)
- Investigation support and documentation
- Letters, scripts, meeting packs and appeal handling
- Support with the conversation itself, if you want a calm, controlled approach
Talk to an expert
Contact us
What this page covers
- Before you act
- Dismissal routes
- Dismissal procedure
- High-risk scenarios
- How we can help
- Staff dismissals FAQs
- Get in touch
Before you dismiss anyone: a quick employer triage
If you take one thing from this page, make it this:
Slow down for 30 minutes and check the route before you act.
Dismissals go wrong when employers:
- start with the outcome (“we need them gone”) instead of the reason
- skip the evidence stage
- treat performance as misconduct (or vice versa)
- forget the paper trail
- let frustration write the letter (never a good idea)
A good starting checklist:
- What’s the real issue? Conduct, performance/capability, redundancy, SOSR?
- What evidence do you actually have? Not “everyone knows”, evidence you can rely on.
- Have you followed your own policies? the right conduct and performance policies protect the business.
- Is there a risk hotspot? (e.g., sickness, pregnancy/maternity, disability, whistleblowing allegations, discrimination risk)
Once those are clear, the process becomes calmer, quicker, and far less stressful.
Dismissal routes: what type of termination is this?
This isn’t about being overly technical, it’s about choosing the correct path so your process matches the situation.
1) Conduct (misconduct)
Use this route where the issue relates to employee behaviour, such as repeated lateness, breaches of company policy, or inappropriate conduct. In more serious cases, including gross misconduct, a formal investigation and disciplinary hearing will usually be required before any decision is made.
2) Capability / performance
Use this route when someone can’t do the job to the required standard, or where health is affecting capability.
This is usually where employers should demonstrate support steps: clarity of expectations, coaching/training, reasonable time, and documented reviews.
3) Redundancy-related dismissals
This applies where the role is no longer required or the business is restructuring. In these situations, a formal consultation process must be followed, with clear legal requirements that differ from misconduct cases.
4) SOSR (Some Other Substantial Reason)
This is the "doesn't fit neatly" route, covering situations like a breakdown in working relationships, irreconcilable differences between employer and employee, or other substantial business reasons that do not fall under conduct, capability, or redundancy. Key point: it needs careful handling and clear reasoning. It is not a shortcut.
A note on contractual changes: Using SOSR to dismiss and re-engage employees on new terms (sometimes called "fire and rehire") is an area of significant legal change. From 2027, this practice will be prohibited under the Employment Rights Act 2025. If you are facing a situation involving proposed changes to employment terms, take advice before acting.
5) Statutory restriction / illegality
Where continued employment would be unlawful (for example, a required licence is lost).
If you’re unsure which route applies, we’ll help you decide quickly because the rest of the process depends on it.
Find your local HR Dept office
Find your local office
The dismissal procedure in practice (a manager-friendly walkthrough)
This is the practical shape of a dismissal process for most SMEs. You don’t need to turn this into a 40-page legal manual, you need to be consistent, evidence-led, and clear.
Step 1: Gather the facts (investigation)
- Collect relevant documents (emails, logs, performance records, policies)
- Speak to the right people
- Document what you found
- Keep it neutral (avoid “proving a point”)
Step 2: Decide whether there is a case to answer
If there isn’t, stop.
If there is, move to a formal meeting stage with written communication.
Step 3: Invite the employee to a meeting (in writing)
Your invite should set expectations:
- what the meeting is about
- what will be discussed
- what documents will be reviewed
- what the possible outcomes could be
- practical details (time/date/location)
Step 4: Hold a fair meeting
Keep the meeting professional and focused:
- explain the issue and evidence
- give the employee a proper chance to respond
- ask fair questions
- take notes
- if new facts emerge, pause and investigate rather than rushing a decision
Step 5: Make a decision and confirm it in writing
Whether the outcome is a warning, an improvement plan, dismissal, or no formal action, confirm it clearly.
If it’s dismissal, confirm:
- the termination date
- notice/pay in lieu (where applicable)
- next steps (return of property, final pay, holiday)
- the right of appeal
Step 6: Offer an appeal route
Appeals protect you as much as they protect the employee, they show fairness and give a structured way to correct issues without escalating conflict.
This is where HR support becomes invaluable: not because you can’t do it, but because employers often struggle to stay consistent when emotions, time pressure, or team politics get involved.
Dismissals with notice vs dismissal without notice
Most dismissals require notice (or pay in lieu of notice). In limited circumstances, typically proven gross misconduct, dismissal may be without notice. Even then, decisions should be evidence-led and handled carefully.
This is an area where employers can accidentally create a breach-of-contract dispute alongside an already stressful situation. If you’re considering dismissal without notice, get advice early.
Get HR Support
High-risk scenarios (where it pays to get help early)
Dismissing someone on long-term sick leave
Termination linked to long-term sickness is one of the most sensitive routes. It often involves:
- medical guidance / occupational health input
- considering support and adjustments
- clear records of decisions and the rationale
- careful communication throughout
Probation and short-service dismissals
These can feel “simple”, but they’re often where employers make rushed decisions and create unnecessary disputes. Get the reason clear, document it, and keep communication professional.
Gross misconduct and “dismissal without notice”
Gross misconduct situations move fast and feel high-stakes. The temptation is to shortcut.
In reality, this is where calm process and evidence matter most, because these cases are more likely to be challenged.
Discrimination risk
If there’s any protected characteristic context, slow down and get advice early. These cases have a very different risk profile and require extra care around reasoning, evidence, consistency, and tone.
How The HR Dept helps with staff dismissals
1) We confirm the safest route
We’ll get clear on the facts and the reason for termination, then advise on the correct process for your situation.
2) We build the paperwork and meeting pack
We can help you create:
- invite letters
- meeting agendas
- investigation summaries
- outcome/dismissal letters
- appeal documentation
- scripts that keep the conversation professional
3) We support (or help lead) difficult meetings
If you’re dreading the meeting, we can attend with you, and where appropriate, help keep the conversation structured and controlled.
4) We help you protect the wider team
A dismissal doesn’t just affect one person. It affects morale, confidence, and culture. We’ll help you handle next steps sensibly.
Talk to an expert
Get your dismissals right
If you’re facing a potential dismissal, speak to us early. The best time to reduce risk is before letters go out and conversations happen.
Staff Dismissals FAQs
Choose the correct route, gather evidence, invite them to a meeting in writing, hold a fair meeting, confirm the decision in writing, and offer an appeal route. The aim is consistency and a clean paper trail.
Termination is the broad umbrella (including resignation and fixed-term end). Dismissal is employer-led termination.
Only in limited circumstances (typically gross misconduct). Even then, you should take an evidence-led approach and handle the process carefully.
It depends on the route (conduct vs performance vs health vs redundancy). It’s usually quicker and safer when the route is clear, evidence is organised, and letters/meetings are handled professionally.
Yes. HR can support the process, documentation, and meeting structure — and where appropriate, help you manage the conversation in a controlled way.
Rushing to the outcome before the route and evidence are clear — and skipping the paper trail.
In short, yes. If an employee is fired, they are terminated from their employment. The reason for a termination depends, it could be for misconduct, poor performance or because they’re not the right fit for a role or company. Regardless of the reason for the dismissal, the employer must let the employee know why they have let them go.
Get HR Support
Contact us
Other services you may be interested in
Starting out
Choosing The Right Path
Navigating Problems
Changing Course
End Of The Road
